Someone’s Leaving. Should You Really Replace Them?

Someone resigns.

The natural response is usually straightforward:

“We need to replace them.”

The old job description is found, the salary is reviewed and recruitment begins.

But before you advertise the vacancy, there is another question worth asking:

If you were creating this role for your business today, would you create exactly the same position?

Quite often, the answer is no.

Businesses change. Roles should too.

Think about what may have changed since that person originally joined.

The business may be larger.

The team around them may have changed.

New technology may have removed some responsibilities and created others.

Customers may expect something different.

Other employees may have developed and taken on more responsibility.

And the plans for the next two or three years may require completely different skills from those that were important when the role was originally created.

Yet when someone leaves, it’s very easy to recruit from the old job description.

That can mean solving yesterday’s problem rather than preparing the business for tomorrow.

Right person. Right seat.

Finding a good person isn’t enough.

You can recruit an excellent candidate and still make the wrong appointment if the role itself hasn’t been properly defined.

Before beginning a recruitment process, ask:

1. Does this role still need to exist in its current form?

If you were designing the team from scratch today, would this position still look the same?

2. What does the business need from this person over the next two or three years?

Recruit for where the business is going, not simply where it has been.

3. Are the responsibilities sitting with the right people?

Roles evolve. Responsibilities get added because somebody is capable, available or simply happens to be there.

A resignation can be an opportunity to reset them.

4. Has the role become more senior or more specialist?

Perhaps you don’t need another manager.

Perhaps you now need a Head of Department.

Or perhaps the opposite is true. The strategic work now sits elsewhere and what the business actually needs is somebody who can deliver.

5. What would success look like 6 or 12 months after they join?

This may be the most important question.

Instead of starting with a list of duties, start with the outcomes.

What should be better because this person joined?

What should they own?

What problems should no longer be sitting with the MD or another member of the team?

What should they have achieved after their first year?

Once those answers are clear, it becomes much easier to define the seat and then find the right person for it.

Recruitment should start before the candidate search

At Parmar Staffing, we don’t believe recruitment should begin with:

“How many CVs can you send me?”

It should begin with understanding the business, the role and what the person in that role actually needs to achieve.

Sometimes that confirms the original brief.

Sometimes it changes the seniority.

Sometimes it changes the responsibilities.

And occasionally it identifies that the business needs a completely different role.

That’s a valuable conversation to have before you start interviewing candidates.

Are you about to replace someone?

Before you reuse the old job description, take another look at it.

Ask yourself:

If we were recruiting this position from scratch today, is this really the person and the role our business needs next?

If you’re not sure, send us the existing job description.

We’ll take a look and have an honest conversation with you about the role, the market and what you’re trying to achieve.

You don’t need to have everything worked out before speaking to us.

Sometimes defining the right seat is the first part of finding the right person.

15% recruitment fee.

Every permanent placement backed by the PSL 100 Day Hiring Promise.

Finding the right people who stay.